A better have a look at Omarosa’s excerpt on Puerto Rico, from a reporter who was there

0
40


The consequence, the brand new e book titled “Unhinged” alleges, was a sluggish and cavalier response to the devastation wrought, particularly when in comparison with Trump’s swift and efficient dealing with of the hurricanes in Texas and Florida weeks earlier.

Manigault Newman, a former senior White Home adviser, would not specify what offensive phrases the Trump administration allegedly used when referring to Puerto Ricans, even when pressed to take action throughout one among her many interviews to advertise her e book.

CNN has not independently verified her claims, and the White Home didn’t reply to CNN’s requests for remark.

I used to be in Puerto Rico when the Category 4 storm tore through the island on September 20. I witnessed a lot of what the e book describes about circumstances and response on the bottom unfold in actual time. The White Home has branded Manigault Newman a liar, and plenty of have questioned her ways, her motives and her accuracy. However based mostly on what I witnessed in Puerto Rico and what I learn in her e book in regards to the hurricane response, this is perhaps one instance the place she bought it proper.

Listed here are three claims the e book made and my evaluation of their veracity.

Declare 1: Trump had a vendetta in opposition to the mayor of San Juan

Within the e book, Manigault Newman says that it might not shock her if Trump was taking out his ire with San Juan Mayor Carmen Yulin Cruz on the individuals of Puerto Rico. “I’d not put it previous Trump to punish the individuals of Puerto Rico to show that lady of shade a lesson,” she wrote.

Certainly, the President did interact in a really public feud with one of many harshest and most vocal critics of his dealing with of the disaster. Yulin Cruz was a frequent presence on tv and did not maintain again her low opinion of Trump and his administration’s response.

“We’re dying, and you might be killing us with the inefficiency and the forms,” Yulin Cruz mentioned at one information convention.

Trump struck again swiftly and fiercely.

“The Mayor of San Juan, who was very complimentary just a few days in the past, has now been advised by the Democrats that you simply have to be nasty to Trump,” the President tweeted on September 30 from his golf membership in Bedminster, New Jersey, the place he was spending the weekend. “Such poor management capacity by the Mayor of San Juan, and others in Puerto Rico, who are usually not in a position to get their staff to assist. They need every little thing to be completed for them when it needs to be a group effort.”

Yulin Cruz advised MSNBC she wasn’t saying something nasty in regards to the President; she simply wished assist.

“Moderately than being a commander-in-chief, he is like a hater-in-chief. He continues to tweet his hate far and wide,” she later advised CNN’s Don Lemon.

Declare 2: The administration’s response was too sluggish

Manigault Newman, who was fired by Kelly final December from her position because the White Home Director of Communications for the Workplace of Public Liaison, additionally places a lot of the blame for what she calls the administration’s “torpid” response immediately on the chief of workers. She says Kelly was sluggish to approve help and that he blamed the island for its troubles following Maria.

No gas. No food. No power. Puerto Ricans fear their future

In these essential first days after the storm, I didn’t see any federal businesses main a sustained rescue and restoration effort. Many Puerto Ricans had been doing a lot of that work themselves, and as individuals grew extra determined and water turned extra scarce, I keep in mind many reporters on the bottom asking, “The place is the Nationwide Guard? The place is FEMA?”

When he was requested — six days after Maria hit — why no federal help had but reached Puerto Rico, Trump defined that it was troublesome “because it’s on the island — it is on an island in the midst of the ocean. It is out within the ocean. You possibly can’t simply drive your vans there from different states.”

I noticed native officers lastly distributing FEMA-provided meals for the primary time greater than every week after I arrived on the island, and never solely did the meals primarily include sweets and ready-to-eat snack objects, additionally described in Manigault Newman’s e book, there have been typically not sufficient to go round.

Within the quick aftermath of Maria, the President gave himself and his administration a 10 — on a scale of 1 to 10 — for the hurricane response to Puerto Rico. However in a report issued final month, FEMA acknowledged that errors had been made. The company concluded it had vastly underestimated the island’s “insufficiently maintained infrastructure.”

Declare 3: Trump and Kelly lacked empathy

The previous White Home adviser wrote that in a nationwide safety assembly after the hurricane struck Puerto Rico, “(Kelly) mentioned, ‘Their infrastructure was already screwed up,’ and recommended the bankrupt authorities was making an attempt to use the hurricane to pressure the US to rebuild their electrical grid.

She mentioned she fought “arm in arm” with former Homeland Safety Adviser Tom Bossert to attempt to advocate for Puerto Rico, however that Kelly shut down these efforts.

The actual fact is, it took Trump two weeks to go to Puerto Rico, at the same time as the pictures dominating the information confirmed shortages of electrical energy, water, meals and gasoline. In distinction, the President was in Texas and Florida inside days after Hurricanes Harvey and Irma hit.

As soon as on the island, Trump certainly complained in regards to the territory’s fiscal issues, at one level saying, “I hate to inform you, Puerto Rico, however you’ve got thrown our finances out of whack.”

He then proceeded to toss rolls of paper towels to victims gathered at a church.

Trump’s response to the lives misplaced was was additionally criticized as callous. He congratulated native officers, telling them they should be proud that — in contrast to Hurricane Katrina — solely 16 individuals died.

“Each dying is a horror, however if you happen to have a look at an actual disaster like Katrina, and also you have a look at the great — a whole bunch and a whole bunch and a whole bunch of those that died, and also you have a look at what occurred right here, with actually a storm that was simply completely overpowering, no person’s ever seen something like this. What’s your dying depend as of this second? Seventeen? Sixteen individuals licensed, 16 individuals versus within the hundreds. You might be very happy with all your individuals and all of our individuals working collectively,” he mentioned then.

We now know that the variety of hurricane-related deaths was severely undercounted. Earlier this month, the Puerto Rican authorities revised the death toll from 64 to greater than 1,400. Many died within the aftermath of the hurricane, resulting from lack of energy, meals and medical care.

Maria Santana, a correspondent for CNN en Español, was amongst CNN’s crew of reporters who lined the devastation of Hurricane Maria in Puerto Rico.



Source link

LEAVE A REPLY

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.